The Surprising Benefits of Overpaying on a Fix and Flip Property: Keeping Your Contractors Busy

When it comes to the world of real estate investing, the concept of overpaying for a property may seem counterintuitive. After all, the goal of any investor is to maximize profits and minimize expenses. However, in the context of fix and flip properties, there’s an intriguing strategy that suggests overpaying can yield unforeseen benefits. By deliberately investing more than market value in a property, investors can keep their contractors busy, creating a symbiotic relationship that ultimately leads to higher returns. In this article, we’ll explore the reasons behind this unconventional approach and shed light on the advantages it offers.

Understanding the Fix and Flip Strategy

Fix and flip real estate investing involves purchasing distressed or undervalued properties, renovating them to enhance their value, and then selling them at a profit. This strategy requires a keen understanding of market trends, property evaluation, and cost-effective renovations. The ultimate goal is to strike a balance between the purchase price, renovation costs, and the potential selling price to ensure a healthy return on investment.

The Traditional Mindset: Minimizing Costs

Conventional wisdom dictates that real estate investors should always aim to secure the lowest possible purchase price to maximize profits. Keeping renovation costs low is also considered a fundamental rule to ensure a successful flip. While this approach makes sense, it often neglects the human factor—the relationships between investors and contractors.

The Contractor Conundrum

Contractors play a crucial role in the fix and flip process. Their skills and efficiency directly impact the renovation timeline and costs. In a fiercely competitive market, skilled contractors can be challenging to secure. A common issue many investors face is keeping contractors consistently engaged. Long gaps between projects can lead to contractors seeking work elsewhere, jeopardizing project timelines and quality.

The Benefits of Overpaying

  1. Guaranteed Priority: By offering contractors consistently higher-paying projects, investors can secure their services more easily. This establishes a mutually beneficial relationship where contractors are more likely to prioritize your projects due to the steady income stream.
  2. Quality and Timeliness: When contractors are confident in a consistent flow of work, they are more likely to focus on delivering high-quality renovations in a timely manner. The sense of job security can translate into increased attention to detail and a reduced likelihood of rushed or subpar work.
  3. Access to Top Talent: Talented contractors are in high demand, and they often have the luxury of choosing projects that offer the best compensation. By overpaying, investors can attract and retain the best talent in the industry, ensuring top-notch workmanship.
  4. Enhanced Reputation: Consistently completing projects on time and to a high standard enhances your reputation as a reliable and trustworthy investor. This, in turn, can attract more deals, partnerships, and opportunities in the long run.
  5. Faster Turnaround: Contractors who are consistently busy with your projects are less likely to delay work due to idle periods. This leads to faster property renovations, enabling quicker turnovers and faster returns on investment.


While overpaying for a fix and flip property might initially seem counterproductive, it’s essential to view it as a strategic investment in a symbiotic relationship with contractors. By prioritizing their needs and ensuring a steady stream of well-compensated work, investors can enjoy faster renovations, higher-quality outcomes, and an improved reputation. The key lies in finding the balance between overpaying and maintaining a profitable margin. Ultimately, this approach challenges conventional wisdom and highlights the multifaceted nature of successful real estate investing.

Steven Gagne

Looking For Investment Properties?

Fill out the form below to join our "Preferred Property Buyers" list and for local real estate updates too!

Enter Your Information Below To Get Immediate Access

... to our HANDYMAN specials. *These are not on the MLS - Many are below $100k. Available properties on the next page.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *